The Conversion Rate Optimization Checklist: 37 Copy and UX Fixes That Actually Move the Needle

Why You Need a Conversion Rate Optimization Checklist

Most conversion rate optimization is random. A designer suggests rounding the button corners. A developer lobbies for lazy-loading images. Someone in the Monday meeting says the page "feels long." So the team spends three weeks A/B testing a green button against an orange one — while the headline communicates nothing, the CTA says "Submit," and there is not a single testimonial on the page.

This is the CRO equivalent of rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic. You are optimizing the wrong things in the wrong order.

A systematic conversion rate optimization checklist solves this by forcing you to evaluate the highest-impact elements first. It ensures that before you touch a button color, you have confirmed that your headline communicates a clear benefit, your value proposition is compelling, your proof is specific and credible, and your CTA tells the visitor exactly what happens next. Those are the elements that swing conversion rates by 50–200%. Button colors swing them by 2–5% — if you are lucky.

I have spent 30+ years writing and testing sales pages, landing pages, VSLs, and email sequences — contributing to $523 million in tracked results. The checklist below is built from that testing history. It is organized by what actually moves conversion rates, not by what is easy to test or what sounds impressive in a conference talk.

How to Use This Checklist

This is not a to-do list to complete in one afternoon. It is an audit framework. Here is the process:

Step 1: Audit your page against each item. Go through the checklist and answer each question honestly. A "no" is not a failure — it is an opportunity you have not captured yet.

Step 2: Prioritize by tier. Tier 1 (copy elements) produces the largest conversion swings. Fix these before touching Tier 2 (design/UX) or Tier 3 (technical). A broken headline with perfect page speed is still a broken page.

Step 3: Test changes one at a time. If you change the headline, CTA, and layout simultaneously, you will never know which change drove the result. Isolate variables. Test one element, measure the result, then move to the next.

Step 4: Re-audit quarterly. Audiences evolve, traffic sources shift, and competitors change their messaging. A page that converted well six months ago may have new gaps. Run the checklist again.

---

Tier 1: Copy Elements (Highest Impact)

These are the conversion rate optimization best practices that produce the largest, most consistent lifts. In my testing experience, copy changes routinely outperform design changes by 5–10x. Start here.

1. Headline Clarity and Specificity

Does your headline communicate the core benefit in under 3 seconds? Read your headline as if you have never seen the page before. Can you immediately understand what is being offered and why it matters? If the headline is clever but unclear — or generic enough to apply to any competitor — it is costing you conversions. The headline carries roughly 80% of your page's performance. A vague headline like "Welcome to Better Marketing" loses to "How to Generate 47 Qualified Leads Per Week Without Increasing Your Ad Spend" every time.

2. Value Proposition Strength

Can a visitor articulate what you offer and why it matters within 5 seconds of landing on the page? Your value proposition is the answer to the visitor's unspoken question: "Why should I care?" If it takes reading three paragraphs to understand what you do and who it is for, most visitors will never get there. The value proposition should be visible above the fold, stated in plain language, and specific enough that it could not describe your competitor.

3. CTA Copy

Does your CTA use a specific action verb that describes the value received — not a generic label like "Submit" or "Learn More"? The difference between "Submit" and "Get My Free Conversion Checklist" is often a 20–40% lift by itself. Your CTA button text should complete the sentence "I want to..." from the visitor's perspective. "Start My Free Trial," "Download the Guide," "Get Your Custom Quote" — these describe what the visitor gets, not what you want them to do.

4. Above-the-Fold Messaging

Is your most compelling message visible without scrolling? A significant percentage of visitors never scroll past the fold. If your strongest benefit, your best social proof, and your primary CTA are all below the fold, you are losing visitors who never see your best material. The above-the-fold section should include the headline, subheadline, a visual element, a trust signal, and a CTA or the path to one.

5. Proof Elements

Are your testimonials, case studies, numbers, and logos specific and credible? "Great product!" is not proof. "We increased our conversion rate from 1.8% to 4.3% in 60 days" is proof. Specific numbers, named individuals, recognizable company logos, and concrete outcomes build credibility. Vague praise builds nothing. Audit every proof element on your page — if it is not specific, replace it with something that is.

6. Objection Handling

Are the top 3–5 objections addressed before the CTA? Every prospect has reasons not to buy. Price, timing, trust, complexity, alternatives — these objections are predictable and consistent within any audience. If your page does not address them, the visitor is left to resolve them alone, and most will resolve them by leaving. List the objections you hear most often in sales conversations and make sure each one is addressed explicitly on the page.

7. Risk Reversal

Is your guarantee, free trial, or money-back promise prominent and clearly stated? Risk reversal removes the final barrier between desire and action. A guarantee buried in 8-point type at the bottom of the page is barely better than no guarantee at all. Make it visible, make it bold, and make the terms clear. "100% money-back guarantee within 30 days, no questions asked" does more conversion work than most people realize.

8. Urgency and Scarcity

Is there a legitimate reason to act now rather than later? Without urgency, "I will come back to this later" becomes the default response — and "later" almost never arrives. Legitimate urgency includes genuine deadlines, limited availability, expiring bonuses, or price increases. The key word is legitimate. Fake countdown timers and manufactured scarcity erode trust and damage long-term conversion rates. If the scarcity is real, communicate it clearly. If it is not real, create a genuine reason instead.

9. Benefit Stacking

Are benefits listed in order of importance to the reader — not importance to you? The benefits that matter most to your prospect should appear first and receive the most emphasis. This seems obvious, but most pages lead with the features the company is proudest of rather than the outcomes the customer cares about most. Survey your customers. Ask what mattered most in their decision. Then reorder your benefit bullets accordingly.

10. Specificity of Claims

Are your claims specific or vague? "$47,000 in 90 days" is a claim that commands attention. "Great results" is wallpaper. Specificity is the currency of credibility — the more precise your numbers, timelines, and outcomes, the more believable they become. Audit every claim on your page and ask: can I make this more specific? If you cannot support a specific claim, find a customer result that you can.

11. Voice-of-Customer Language

Does the copy use the words your prospects actually use to describe their problems and desires? The best conversion copy is not written — it is discovered. It comes from mining customer reviews, support tickets, sales calls, and forum posts for the exact language your audience uses. When your headline echoes the words in a prospect's head, it creates an instant recognition response that no amount of polished copywriting can replicate.

12. Readability and Scannability

Is the page formatted for scanners — short paragraphs, descriptive subheads, bullet points, and bold key phrases? Most visitors scan before they read. If your page is a wall of text with no visual entry points, scanners will bounce before they find the content that would have persuaded them. Subheads should tell a story on their own — a visitor who reads only the subheads should understand the core argument and feel compelled to read the details.

13. Price Framing

Is the price anchored, compared, or contextualized — rather than stated in isolation? A price without context triggers sticker shock. A price compared to the cost of the problem, the value of the outcome, or the price of alternatives feels reasonable. "The full program is $997 — less than the cost of one unoptimized month of ad spend" reframes the price from expense to investment. If you are not framing your price, you are letting the visitor frame it for you — and they will frame it as a cost.

14. Emotional Triggers

Does the copy connect with the reader's core pain or desire — not just their rational interest? People make buying decisions emotionally and justify them logically. If your page is purely logical — features, specifications, process descriptions — it is missing the engine that drives action. Identify the emotional core of your audience's problem. Is it fear of falling behind? Frustration with wasted effort? Desire for recognition? The psychology behind persuasive copy should be woven into the messaging, not bolted on as an afterthought.

15. Story and Narrative

Is there a compelling narrative that pulls the reader through the page — or is it a disconnected collection of sections? The most persuasive pages follow a narrative arc: they establish a problem, escalate the stakes, introduce a turning point, and resolve with the offer. This is the architecture behind frameworks like AIDA and PAS. A page with a narrative feels like a conversation. A page without one feels like a brochure. If your page reads like a list of disconnected selling points, restructure it around a story that carries the reader from problem to solution.

---

Tier 2: Design and UX Elements (Medium Impact)

These conversion rate optimization techniques produce meaningful lifts — typically 10–50% — but they amplify strong copy rather than compensating for weak copy. A beautiful layout with a broken headline is still a low-converting page. Fix Tier 1 first, then optimize these.

16. Visual Hierarchy

Does the eye follow the intended path — headline to subheadline to proof to CTA? Visual hierarchy is the design equivalent of a persuasion sequence. If the visitor's eye lands on a sidebar testimonial before reading the headline, the persuasion architecture is broken. Use size, contrast, color, and spacing to guide the eye through your page in the order that builds the strongest case for conversion.

17. Mobile Optimization

Does the page work — not just display, but actually work — on phones? More than half of web traffic is mobile. "Works on mobile" means more than responsive layout. It means the headline is legible without zooming, the CTA button is thumb-sized and easy to tap, forms are simple to complete on a small screen, and the above-the-fold experience communicates the value proposition clearly on a 6-inch display. Test on actual devices, not just browser emulators.

18. Form Friction

Are you asking for only the information you genuinely need? Every form field you add reduces conversions. Name and email convert better than name, email, and phone. Name and email convert better still when only email is required. Audit your form: for each field, ask "Do we need this to deliver the promised value?" If the answer is no, remove it. You can always collect additional information after the conversion.

19. Page Speed

Does the page load in under 3 seconds on both desktop and mobile? Slow pages bleed visitors before they see a single word of your copy. After 3 seconds, bounce rates increase dramatically. Compress images, minimize scripts, leverage browser caching, and use a CDN. Page speed is a foundational element — it does not create conversions, but a slow page actively prevents them.

20. Button Visibility and Prominence

Is the CTA button visually prominent — the most obvious interactive element on the page? The CTA button should be impossible to miss. It should contrast with the surrounding page, be large enough to command attention, and appear at every decision point — not just at the bottom. If a visitor is ready to convert, the button should be within a scroll's reach no matter where they are on the page.

21. White Space and Visual Breathing Room

Is the page clean and uncluttered — or does it feel dense and overwhelming? White space is not wasted space. It is a design tool that directs attention, improves readability, and makes key elements stand out. A cluttered page with too many competing elements creates cognitive overload, which is the enemy of conversion. When in doubt, remove elements rather than adding them.

22. Image Relevance

Do your images support the message — or are they generic stock photos that add nothing? Relevant images — product screenshots, real customer photos, before-and-after comparisons, data visualizations — reinforce the copy and build credibility. Generic stock photos of people shaking hands or staring at laptops are visual noise. Every image on the page should answer the question: "Does this help the visitor understand, believe, or desire the offer?"

23. Navigation Simplicity

Is the path to conversion clear and unobstructed — or are there competing links, menus, and distractions? On a dedicated landing page, the answer is simple: remove all navigation. On other page types, minimize navigation options and make the conversion path the most prominent option. Every link that is not the CTA is a potential exit. Audit your page for links and ask: "Does this link serve the conversion goal?"

24. Trust Indicators

Are security badges, payment logos, certifications, and other trust signals present and visible — especially near the CTA and checkout? Trust indicators reduce the perceived risk of converting. SSL badges near forms, payment provider logos near checkout, industry certifications near claims, and privacy assurances near email captures — each one removes a micro-objection that might otherwise stop the conversion.

25. Color Contrast and Readability

Is all text easily readable, and does the CTA button contrast sharply with its surroundings? Low-contrast text creates friction. A CTA button that blends into the page gets overlooked. Test your page by squinting at it — the headline and CTA should still be the most prominent elements. Accessibility is not just ethical; it is a conversion factor. Text that is hard to read is text that does not convert.

26. Directional Cues

Do visual elements — arrows, eye gaze in photos, layout flow — point toward the CTA rather than away from it? Directional cues are subtle but measurable. A testimonial photo where the person's gaze points toward the CTA button outperforms one where they look away. An arrow graphic pointing toward the form outperforms one pointing into empty space. Audit every visual element for directional impact.

27. Consistent Messaging (Message Match)

Does the page headline and offer match the ad, email, or link that sent the visitor there? Message match is one of the most overlooked conversion rate optimization tips. When a visitor clicks an ad promising "5 Free Landing Page Templates" and lands on a page with the headline "Welcome to Our Marketing Resources," the disconnect kills conversions. The transition from traffic source to landing page should feel seamless — same language, same promise, same visual tone.

---

Tier 3: Technical and Analytics (Foundation)

These items do not produce large conversion lifts on their own, but without them, you cannot measure results, identify problems, or scale what works. Think of Tier 3 as the foundation — necessary but not sufficient.

28. Analytics Tracking

Are conversions being measured accurately — with proper goal setup, event tracking, and attribution? You cannot optimize what you cannot measure. Verify that your analytics platform is tracking the actual conversion event (form submission, purchase, sign-up), not just pageviews. Check that conversion goals are configured correctly, that tracking code fires on the thank-you page, and that attribution models reflect your actual traffic sources.

29. Heatmap and Session Recording Setup

Do you have heatmaps and session recordings running on your key pages? Analytics tells you what happened. Heatmaps and session recordings tell you why. Where do visitors click? How far do they scroll? Where do they hesitate or rage-click? This data reveals friction points, ignored CTAs, and content that visitors skip — insights that inform your next round of Tier 1 and Tier 2 optimizations.

30. A/B Testing Infrastructure

Can you run controlled split tests — sending equal traffic to two page variations and measuring which converts better? Without A/B testing, every change is a guess. With it, every change is a data point. Ensure you have a testing tool installed, that it integrates with your analytics, and that you have enough traffic to reach statistical significance within a reasonable timeframe. If traffic is too low for page-level tests, start with email subject line tests to build the testing habit.

31. Cross-Browser and Cross-Device Testing

Have you verified that the page renders and functions correctly across major browsers and devices? A page that converts well on Chrome desktop but breaks on Safari mobile is leaving money on the table. Test on Chrome, Safari, Firefox, and Edge — on both desktop and mobile. Pay special attention to forms, pop-ups, and interactive elements, which are the most likely to break across environments.

32. Broken Links and 404 Errors

Have you checked every link on the page — including CTA buttons, navigation links, and footer links — for 404 errors? A broken CTA link is a conversion killer that produces zero error messages for the visitor — they click, nothing happens, and they leave. Run a link audit on every page in your conversion path and fix any broken links immediately.

33. SSL Certificate and Security

Does the page load over HTTPS with a valid SSL certificate? An SSL certificate is table stakes. Browsers flag non-HTTPS pages with security warnings that destroy trust instantly. Verify that your SSL certificate is current, that all page resources load over HTTPS (no mixed content warnings), and that the padlock icon displays correctly.

34. Thank-You Page Optimization

Does your thank-you page do more than say "thanks" — does it advance the relationship? The thank-you page is the most neglected page in most funnels. The visitor just converted — they are at peak engagement and receptivity. Use the thank-you page to set expectations, offer a logical next step (a related resource, a consultation booking, a product upsell), and reinforce that they made a smart decision. A well-structured funnel treats the thank-you page as an opportunity, not an afterthought.

35. Email Capture for Non-Converters

Do you have a mechanism to capture email addresses from visitors who are interested but not ready to convert on your primary offer? Not every visitor is ready to buy or sign up today. An exit-intent popup, a content upgrade, or a secondary CTA offering a lower-commitment resource captures leads that would otherwise be lost. These visitors already showed interest by visiting your page — an email sequence gives you the chance to convert them over time.

36. Retargeting Pixel Installation

Are retargeting pixels installed and firing correctly on your key pages? Most visitors will not convert on their first visit. Retargeting allows you to re-engage them with targeted ads across platforms. Verify that your Facebook, Google, and any other relevant retargeting pixels are installed on both the landing page and the thank-you page — the landing page pixel builds your retargeting audience, and the thank-you page pixel excludes converters.

37. Page Indexation and SEO Basics

Is the page properly indexed (or deliberately noindexed) and meeting basic SEO requirements? For pages that should attract organic traffic, verify that the page is indexable, has a unique title tag and meta description, uses proper heading hierarchy, and includes relevant internal links. For paid-traffic-only landing pages that you do not want indexed, verify that the noindex tag is in place so the page does not compete with your main site pages.

---

How to Prioritize: The Impact-First Approach

If you audited your page against all 37 items and found gaps in every tier, resist the temptation to start with the quick fixes. Start at the top.

Tier 1 copy elements produce the largest conversion swings — routinely 50–200% or more. A rewritten headline, a restructured value proposition, or a specific-and-credible testimonial replacing a vague one can double conversion rates in a single test. These are the changes worth testing first because they have the highest expected value.

Tier 2 design and UX elements amplify strong copy. Once your messaging is working — your headline stops visitors, your proof builds trust, your CTA earns clicks — then visual hierarchy, mobile optimization, and form friction become the levers that squeeze additional percentage points. A clean layout makes good copy perform better. But a clean layout cannot rescue bad copy.

Tier 3 technical elements are the foundation that makes everything measurable and functional. Fix any broken tracking, broken links, or broken rendering immediately — these are not optimization items, they are infrastructure. Then use the analytics and testing tools to measure the impact of your Tier 1 and Tier 2 changes.

The mistake I see most often is teams spending months on Tier 3 — installing tools, configuring dashboards, debating testing platforms — while the headline on their highest-traffic page says "Welcome" and their CTA says "Submit." The tools do not convert visitors. The copy does. Start there.

If you want a professional audit of your pages against this checklist — or need the copy rewritten to close the gaps — let's talk about your conversion goals. I have been optimizing pages and writing conversion-focused copy for over 30 years, and every engagement starts with exactly this kind of systematic audit.